Skip to main content
All judges
C
Justice Carthy
Court of Appeal for Ontario
Reported rulings
10
Practice focus
Commercial, Employment
Outcomes · all rulings
Defendant prevailed
70%
Mixed / split
20%
Plaintiff prevailed
10%
Based on 10 reported rulings. Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results.
Curia · Appearance strategy

Run heavy on record-based arguments. This judge is historically receptive to plaintiff submissions grounded in contemporaneous medical records. Narrative-heavy expert opinions without corroborating documentation are more likely to be discounted.

Sign up for AI-generated appearance strategy

Sign up free
Recent rulings
Case
Citation
Date
Gismondi v. Toronto (City of)
2003 CanLII 52143 (ON CA)
Apr 29, 2003
Riel v. Holland
2003 CanLII 3433 (ON CA)
Jan 1, 2003
Young v. Ontario (Minister of Finance)
2003 CanLII 23640 (ON CA)
Jan 1, 2003
─────────────────
─────────
────
─────────────────
─────────
────
─────────────────
─────────
────

Sign up to see all 10 rulings

Sign up free
Sign up

Get the full picture on Justice Carthy.

AI preparation briefs, complete case summaries, and research tools for Ontario counsel.

Start free